The root and the bridge
Offnets has two pillars in philosophy. Aristotle gives the content: what is kept, and why. Michael Sandel gives the form: how a rule is organized and how it changes.
Sandel is, to a large extent, a modern reader of Aristotle. At Offnets the order was the same: first we read Sandel, and the structure of the Constitution came from him; then we went to the source, Aristotle, and the content came from him.
The wisdom you only learn by living
Aristotle calls practical wisdom phronesis (Nicomachean Ethics, VI). It is not learned from books: it is acquired only by living through cases, over time. It is the pillar of the manifesto: intelligence is not on the internet, it is in people. Offnets exists to keep phronesis and let it circulate.
Matter and form
In the Physics and the Metaphysics, every thing has a matter, a form and an end. The raw conversation is the matter. The lesson, the notebook and the rule are the form. Wisdom is the end (Art. 1).
Opinions and puzzles
Aristotle's method starts from the respected opinions (endoxa), lays out the puzzles (aporiai) and arrives at what survives them (Topics I; Nicomachean Ethics VII.1). It is the method of every notebook: who holds what, where they disagree, what survives.
The Lyceum
The Lyceum was a place before it was a school: a grove with a gymnasium, outside the walls of Athens, where Aristotle came to teach.
Walking and talking
Teaching was conversation while walking. The peripatos was the covered walkway where they strolled, and the name stuck to the school: the Peripatetics.
Two lessons a day
Aulus Gellius (Attic Nights XX.5) tells of two sessions. In the morning, the acroamatic lessons, in depth, for the close circle. In the afternoon, the exoteric ones, open to the public.
The lecture notes
What reached us from Aristotle are not books written for publication. They are, to a large extent, his lecture notes, revised over the years. The Nicomachean Ethics is a course of lessons.
The compilation into treatises
Those notes were gathered into treatises (pragmateiai). The body we read today was organized in the 1st century BC by Andronicus of Rhodes: a set of lessons became a work.
Collective research and the cited document
The Lyceum also researched as a group. The students compiled the constitutions of 158 cities and the list of the victors of the games at Delphi: official documents, cited as raw material, from which the synthesis was then drawn.
From this comes an Offnets principle for what is written. A document that circulated among people and is not on the internet enters the notebook as a cited source, with its origin and who brought it, not as speech. What is published on the internet enters only as a reference. It is a principle under discussion: the direction, not a finished feature.
The rhythm of the notebook
The Offnets notebook follows the rhythm of the Lyceum.
Was there a meeting? There is a notebook. The whole week? There is a compilation.
The notebook's messages do not quote Aristotle. The philosophy stays behind them.
Friendship, ownership and use
Community and friendship
For Aristotle, a community (koinonia) is held together by friendship (philia), and a friend is another self. He distinguishes three friendships: the one of utility ends when its reason ends; the one that lasts is the friendship of those who trust each other. At Offnets, the meeting around a mission is the first. The circle of trust is the one that lasts.
Private ownership, common use among friends
In the Politics (II), against Plato's common property, Aristotle defends private ownership and common use among friends. It is Art. 15: the brain stays with its owner, on the owner's machine; its use is shared by consent.
We deliberate about means, not ends
No one deliberates about the end; we deliberate about the means to reach it (Nicomachean Ethics, III). It is Art. 13: the owner sets the end, the emissary chooses only the means, and its authority ends when the mission ends.
Truthfulness
Truthfulness is the mean between boastfulness and false modesty (Nicomachean Ethics, IV): neither inflating nor shrinking what one knows. It is Art. 14: silence is allowed; invention is not.
The wax tablet
The Greeks wrote on wax tablets, and Plato, in the Theaetetus, compares memory to a block of wax that takes the imprint of what is perceived. It is the symbol of the phone at Offnets: the tablet that walks with its owner and takes the imprint of what was said. Today the tablet is in trial: the direction, not a finished feature.
The liturgy
In Athens, a liturgy was a public service paid for by those who had the means, and magnificence was spending well on what belongs to everyone (Nicomachean Ethics, IV). Whoever funded it received honor, not control. That is the rule for anyone who wants to fund the network: public honor, never power over what it keeps.
Justice, and the form of the Constitution
Michael J. Sandel, a Harvard professor, presents in Justice three ways of thinking about what is just: maximizing welfare, respecting freedom, cultivating virtue and the common good. The third is Aristotle, and it is the one Sandel himself defends.
The structure of the Constitution came from the book: three layers, with rights above distribution and distribution above government; no gain in utility buys an exception to a right; the law changes by proposal with public reason; and each decided case becomes precedent.
The situated self
In his critique of John Rawls (Liberalism and the Limits of Justice, 1982), Sandel argues that no one chooses their principles as an unencumbered self, outside the communities that formed them. We are situated selves. It is the Offnets idea of community: we are formed by the communities we belong to.
What money can't buy
When a thing enters the market, the language of the market changes what it is (What Money Can't Buy, 2012). That is why the content of a brain is never sold, there is no "sponsored by" inside a notebook, and whoever teaches is not treated as an input.
Contributive justice
In The Tyranny of Merit (2020), Sandel defends the dignity of those who contribute to the common good. At Offnets, a seat is the right of whoever wants to learn and to teach, never a ranking prize.
The flutes
The best-known example in Justice comes from Aristotle: the best flutes should go to the best flute players, because justice looks to the purpose of the thing. The purpose of a seat at Offnets is to learn and to teach. That is why it goes to whoever wants to learn and to teach, by invitation, and not to whoever pays the most.
Where Sandel parts ways
Sandel inherits from Aristotle the question of purpose and honor, but rejects natural hierarchy and teleology as a science of nature. He keeps the method: deliberating in public about the common good.
Where they don't help
Aristotle's polis excluded slaves, women and foreigners. We inherit the method (purpose, virtue, friendship), never the exclusion. For him, virtue is formed in a small, stable community; the network will grow beyond that, and that is why, in the Constitution, rights come before virtue.
Sandel is a philosopher of deliberation, not of engineering. He says nothing about cryptography, signatures or machine scale. That remains engineering.
Aristotle is the root. Sandel is the bridge.
Bibliography
The pillars
- Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics; Politics; Physics; Metaphysics; Topics.
- Michael J. Sandel. Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? (2009).
- Michael J. Sandel. Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (1982).
- Michael J. Sandel. What Money Can't Buy (2012).
- Michael J. Sandel. The Tyranny of Merit (2020).
The Lyceum
- Aulus Gellius. Attic Nights, XX.5 (the acroamatic and exoteric lessons).
- Plato. Theaetetus (memory as a block of wax).
- The Aristotelian corpus as course notes, edited by Andronicus of Rhodes (1st century BC); the Constitution of the Athenians and the Lyceum's collection of 158 constitutions.
Next in line
- Michael Walzer. Spheres of Justice (1983): each sphere has its own rules (Art. 12).
- Marcel Mauss. Essai sur le don (1925), The Gift: giving, receiving and giving back.
- Helen Nissenbaum. Privacy in Context (2010): privacy as contextual integrity.
- Richard M. Titmuss. The Gift Relationship (1970): giving loses when it becomes a market.
- Elinor Ostrom. Governing the Commons (1990): a community governs a commons without market or state.
Inspiration summarized in our own words. None of these authors is an author of the protocol, and none of them endorses it. The constitution and the protocol are our own. Like them, this page is clay: it changes by version, always dated.